Restrictions OK
Jurisdiction Employment Relations Authority - Auckland
Reference No AA 303/07
Hearing date 25 Jun 2007
Determination date 03 October 2007
Member R A Monaghan
Representation G Pollak ; P Luxford
Location Auckland
Parties Bartley v Grasshoppers Lawnmowing Services Ltd
Summary JURISDICTION - UNJUSTIFIED DISMISSAL – Whether person intending to work – Applicant alleged offered and accepted employment – Respondent denied making offer and considered exchange about terms and conditions a general discussion about position – Alleged later attempted to contact applicant, and when he did not respond, it appointed someone else – Applicant did not accept respondent mailed documents and submitted it simply changed its mind and failed to advise him – Respondent sought employee in response to new contract with client – At date of alleged offer contract not finalised – Unlikely respondent would make express offer at that time – Not made clear to applicant that job description being provided to other candidates – Situation exacerbated by parties differing use of “would” e.g. applicant indicated “would accept” salary, which respondent took as indication of interest in position , not acceptance of offer – Authority of view miscommunication led to problem, rather than change of mind on respondent’s part – No offer and acceptance – No employment relationship created - Gardener
Result Application dismissed ; Costs reserved
Main Category Personal Grievance
Statutes ERA s5;ERA s6(1)(b)(ii)
Number of Pages 9
PDF File Link: aa 303_07.pdf [pdf 32 KB]