Restrictions OK
Jurisdiction Employment Relations Authority - Christchurch
Reference No CA 178/08
Hearing date 21 Nov 2008
Determination date 27 November 2008
Member J Crichton
Representation G Amey (in person) ; no appearance
Location Nelson
Parties Amey v Komene & Anor
Other Parties Komene
Summary PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - Identity of employer - Application to reopen personal grievance - No appearance for respondent - When employment relationship ended, applicant raised personal grievance and notified employer of outstanding wages - Parties reached full and final settlement of matters between them at mediation, with applicant not pursuing personal grievance and respondent paying outstanding wages by instalments - Respondent failed to fully honour settlement agreement - Applicant alleged respondents misrepresented themselves in mediated settlement as limited liability company, Sharvai Enterprises Limited (“S”), when in fact traded as partnership - Authority found appeared was never company incorporated as S - Insofar as operators of S represented had benefits of limited liability operators in breach of Companies Act 1993 - Authority satisfied applicant employed by respondents, not S - Applicant sought to set aside mediated settlement, given breaches by respondents, and reintroduce personal grievance claim - Authority satisfied applicant prevented from doing so by s149(3) Employment Relations Act 2000 - Application dismissed - ARREARS OF WAGES - Applicant still owed outstanding wages and other monies pursuant to mediated settlement - Respondents to pay outstanding wages - PENALTY - Applicant settled rather than pursuing personal grievance claim, facilitating prompt resolution - Respondent flagrantly breached settlement agreement and applicant now prevented from reopening personal grievance - Authority satisfied appropriate case to award penalty - $4,000 penalty awarded, payable to applicant - COSTS - Costs to lie where they fall - Truck driver
Result Application dismissed (Reopening of personal grievance) ; Arrears of wages ($1,777.84) ; Application granted (Penalty)($4,000)(payable to applicant) ; Costs to lie where they fall
Main Category Practice & Procedure
Statutes Companies Act 1993;ERA s149(3);ERA s149(4)
Number of Pages 5
PDF File Link: ca 178_08.pdf [pdf 20 KB]